Bay Burrito Co. is a hidden gem tucked away on the back side of Main Street in Sutton Bay, offering fresh, made-to-order burritos with a variety of flavorful ingredients. With a build-your-own approach, they craft each burrito right in front of you, ensuring a delicious and personalized experience. Only open in the summer and shoulder seasons, their hours can be a bit unpredictable, a quick call ahead ensures you won’t miss out on their tasty creations.